Creamy Dill Egg Salad Sandwiches: A Toasty Take on the Classic Egg Salad

A Classic Egg Salad Sandwich, But Make It Extra

Let’s be honest—egg salad sandwiches have a bit of a reputation. You either love ’em, or you’ve only had the sad, soggy kind that lives in plastic containers at gas stations. But friends, we’re rewriting that narrative today.

This Creamy Dill Egg Salad Sandwich on Toasted Bread is everything the classic egg salad should be—but brighter, fresher, and with a little dill-icious twist (sorry, couldn’t help myself). Whether you’re packing lunch for work, wrangling a toddler while trying to eat something nutritious, or just want a nostalgic bite with a grown-up upgrade, this recipe’s got your back.

Why You’ll Love This Egg Salad Sandwich

• It’s fast. No one has time to be peeling eggs for 30 minutes.
• It’s full of flavor. Dijon mustard + lemon juice + dill = a zippy, fresh combo that cuts through the richness.
• It’s lunchbox-approved. It holds up well and actually tastes better after it sits a bit.
• It’s easy to customize. Got picky eaters? Skip the onions. Want more crunch? Add extra celery.

Whether you’re a lifelong fan of egg salad or giving it another shot after a bad break-up (we see you), this recipe might just rekindle the flame.

Ingredients You’ll Need

• 6 large eggs
• ¼ cup mayonnaise
• 1 tbsp Dijon mustard
• 1 tbsp chopped fresh dill
• 1 celery stalk, finely diced
• 1 tbsp red onion, finely chopped
• 1 tsp lemon juice
• Salt and black pepper, to taste
• 4 slices of whole grain bread, toasted
• Butter lettuce or romaine leaves (optional but delightful)

How to Make Creamy Dill Egg Salad Sandwiches

Sometimes the simplest dishes hold the most comfort—and this creamy dill egg salad sandwich is proof that humble ingredients, when treated right, can deliver an unforgettable bite. Whether you’re whipping this up for a light lunch, packing it for a picnic, or just looking to clean out the fridge, this timeless recipe always hits the spot. Let’s break it down like a pro, step by step.

Step 1: Boil the Eggs – Perfect Every Time

Start with fresh large eggs. Carefully arrange the eggs in a medium saucepan, then pour in enough cold water to submerge them with about an inch of water above the top. Set the pot over medium-high heat. The moment the water reaches a steady boil, remove the pot from the heat, cover it with a lid, and set a timer for 10 to 12 minutes. This off-heat method gently finishes the cooking, yielding perfectly cooked yolks that are bright, firm, and never chalky. No need to hover or stir—this is a near foolproof technique every chef swears by.

Step 2: Chill & Peel Like a Pro

Once the time’s up, drain the hot water and immediately shock the eggs in a bowl of ice water. If you don’t have ice on hand, running cold tap water over them for a few minutes will do. Cooling the eggs quickly stops the cooking and makes them much easier to peel. Crack the shell all over by rolling it gently on the counter, then peel under a stream of cold water for a smooth, frustration-free process. Roughly chop the eggs—not too fine. You want texture in your salad, not mush.

Step 3: Whip Up the Creamy Dream Dressing

In a mixing bowl, whisk together ¼ cup of high-quality mayonnaise, 1 tablespoon of Dijon mustard, 1 tablespoon of freshly chopped dill, and a splash of lemon juice—about a teaspoon. Season it lightly with a pinch of kosher salt and a dash of freshly ground black pepper for balance.Whisk it all together until the dressing is smooth and glossy. The aroma should be fresh, tangy, and herbaceous—this dressing is the soul of your egg salad.

Step 4: Combine with Care

To the bowl of dressing, add your chopped eggs, 1 finely diced celery stalk, and 1 tablespoon of minced red onion. With a silicone spatula or wooden spoon, gently fold the mixture until everything is evenly coated and well combined—take your time to keep the texture light and chunky.Avoid overmixing—you want to see distinct pieces of egg and vegetable. The end result should be creamy with a bit of crunch from the celery and a subtle zing from the red onion.

Step 5: Toast, Stack & Serve

Take slices of whole grain or sourdough bread and toast them until golden brown. This adds a delightful crunch and structure to the sandwich. For extra freshness and color, lay down a few leaves of butter lettuce or romaine on the bottom slice. Spoon a generous helping of the egg salad over the greens, then cap it with another slice of toast. Slice diagonally (because it just tastes better that way), and serve immediately.

Final Touch: Make It Yours

This recipe is a solid base, but feel free to put your spin on it—swap in Greek yogurt for part of the mayo, add chopped chives or capers for an extra punch, or layer on sliced tomatoes or avocado for a fresh twist. With this technique and dressing as your foundation, your egg salad game just went from standard to stellar.

Cooking Tips from My Kitchen to Yours

• Old eggs peel easier. For best results, choose eggs that aren’t freshly laid—ones that have been refrigerated for a few days tend to peel more easily after boiling. Fresher ones can cling to their shells like it’s a bad breakup.
• Let it chill. If you have time, pop the salad in the fridge for 15–30 minutes. It helps the flavors mingle (like a good happy hour).
• Sub swaps: Out of dill? Try chives or parsley. Not a Dijon fan? Yellow mustard will still give you a nice kick.
• Don’t skip the lemon juice. It’s the little pop that brightens everything—like highlighter for your tastebuds.

Nutritional Value of Creamy Dill Egg Salad Sandwiches

Creamy Dill Egg Salad Sandwiches aren’t just delicious—they’re also a wholesome option that brings a good mix of protein, healthy fats, and essential nutrients to your plate. Here’s why this sandwich strikes the perfect balance between comfort and nutrition.”

At the heart of the recipe are eggs, a powerhouse of nutrition. Each egg contributes about 6 grams of high-quality protein, helping to keep you full and energized. They’re also rich in important vitamins like B12, which supports brain function, and vitamin D, which helps regulate calcium for strong bones. Eggs are also a natural source of choline—a key nutrient that supports metabolism and plays a vital role in brain health

Mayonnaise, while often seen as indulgent, provides healthy fats—particularly when you opt for a good-quality version made with avocado oil or olive oil. These fats support brain health and help your body absorb fat-soluble vitamins. A moderate amount keeps the salad creamy and flavorful without overpowering the nutritional balance. Meanwhile, Dijon mustard adds zing with virtually no calories or fat, and fresh dill adds antioxidants and micronutrients like manganese and vitamin A.

The inclusion of red onion and celery adds more than just crunch—they contribute fiber, antioxidants, and small doses of vitamins like C and K. Celery also contains natural anti-inflammatory compounds and is low in calories, making it a smart addition for both texture and health benefits.

Lemon juice gives a subtle tang while boosting the vitamin C content, which supports your immune system and helps enhance iron absorption from other foods you eat throughout the day. A touch of salt and freshly ground pepper rounds out the seasoning—just enough to elevate the flavors without tipping into excessive sodium levels, especially if you’re mindful with your portions.
Layer it on whole grain bread, and you’ve got a well-rounded meal with extra fiber and lasting energy Whole grains add fiber to support digestion, help regulate blood sugar levels, and keep you feeling satisfied longer. Toss in a few crisp lettuce leaves for a boost of fiber and moisture—an easy way to lighten things up without adding extra calories.

Altogether, a single sandwich provides a good balance of protein (around 15–20g), fats (especially healthy ones), fiber (from the vegetables and whole grain bread), and essential vitamins. It’s a smart choice for a light lunch or post-workout meal—comforting yet clean, filling without being heavy.

A Little Story from Lily’s Table

This sandwich became my go-to when I was juggling a toddler on my hip and a deadline on my laptop. It’s quick, satisfying, and made me feel like I was doing something good for myself (instead of sneaking snacks off my kid’s plate). Now, it’s a lunchbox staple at our house—and no one’s complaining.

FAQs About Egg Salad Sandwiches

Can I make this egg salad ahead of time?
Absolutely. It actually tastes better the next day. Store it in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 3 days.

Can I use Greek yogurt instead of mayo?
Yes! Greek yogurt adds a nice tang and cuts down the richness. I’d start with half mayo, half yogurt to balance it out.

What’s the best bread for egg salad sandwiches?
Toasted whole grain bread gives a nice hearty bite, but you can go wild—brioche, sourdough, or even a croissant if you’re feeling fancy.

How do I keep my sandwich from getting soggy?
Add a layer of lettuce between the bread and the egg salad to act as a moisture barrier. Or prep the filling and toast separately, then assemble just before eating.

Craving More Sandwich Magic?

If you love bold flavors like this, you’ll want to try these other reader-favorites:

• Roasted Veggie and Hummus Sandwich – Perfect for Meatless Mondays
• Zesty Chicken Salad with Grapes – A juicy twist on the classic
• Savory Avocado Toast with Pickled Onions – For breakfast or anytime

Until next time, happy cooking—and don’t forget to check out more lunch-worthy ideas on MealsBang!

Join our foodie family on Facebook and Instagram for more kitchen inspiration!

xo,
Lily 🍳🥪💛